I think that you can not devide the posts in a forum in black and white only. Meaning thatt here are always cases where though the post may not violate any rules, still be inapropriate.
For example I can still remember that psot about peeing in the game and so on. It didnt violate any forum rules but still it was not adding noting to the game discussion.
I think each moderator should have some room in order to make personal valoration of the post and if it may contribite to the communite or no.
Also we all msut have in mind that these are privetely run forums and we are just guests. We have no right to demand anything. We have the freedom to leave if we dont like it.
